PostPublius
U.S. national edition · Reporting checked

Markets · Column

Why did my index fund fall when so many stocks went up?

Thursday’s losses reached most of the S&P 500. Friday morning, a smaller group of falling stocks could outweigh the winners.

By Victor Julian Hale · Written

Because the biggest companies can fall hard enough to outweigh the winners.

Thursday, November 19, was a broad retreat. The S&P 500 closed at 7,175.83, down 2.02%, and more than 90% of its stocks fell, according to AP’s closing report.

Friday, November 20, told a different story. In AP’s 11:08 a.m. Eastern snapshot, the index was down 1.4% even though more of its stocks were rising than falling. That was a morning observation, not Friday’s close.

The explanation is weight. The S&P 500 weights companies according to the market value of their publicly tradable shares. A fund tracking that index follows those weights. A very large company therefore matters much more to its movement than a small constituent. That is the consequence of S&P’s weighting method.

Here is an invented $100 example. One company accounts for $50; nine others share the remaining $50. The big company falls 4%, costing $2. Each of the other nine rises 1%, adding 50 cents altogether. You finish with $98.50: down 1.5%, despite nine winners and one loser.

Owning hundreds of companies can spread exposure without spreading it evenly. A cheerful count of rising stocks cannot tell you how an index fund performed.

Nor can that index quote tell you what happened to every retirement account. Your result depends on your holdings. A mutual fund’s per-share net asset value is generally calculated after the market closes; an intraday index reading is not that calculation. Investor.gov explains the distinction.

The useful fact to watch is whether losses remain concentrated in the largest companies or spread across the market. First establish which index your fund actually tracks. Market coverage owes readers an explanation of what moved their dollars before telling them how worried to feel.