A client buys legal judgment in the hope of bringing a dispute to a defensible end. In hourly private civil practice, the lawyer earns fees for time spent working on it. More work can produce a larger bill without producing a resolution. The client needs a way forward; the invoice can account for hours without explaining whether they supplied one.
That tension deserves scrutiny. It does not establish misconduct, and hourly practice does not describe representation generally.
Gallup’s September 1–17, 2026 poll found 46% of U.S. adults had a great deal or fair amount of trust in the federal judicial branch headed by the Supreme Court, compared with 67% in 2020. That is broader than Supreme Court job approval and narrower than confidence in all courts. The survey does not test whether fees caused the decline. My argument is that a process whose costs seem detached from its purpose gives people another reason to distrust the justice it promises.
But quick resolution is not always just resolution. A lawyer demanding withheld records or rejecting an inadequate offer may be doing exactly what the client needs. Delay can favor the better-funded litigant, who can afford to wait while the other side’s resources disappear. A person with a sound claim needs a lawyer willing to press it. Rewarding lawyers merely for closing files could reward surrender.
The ABA’s model rules leave the settlement decision with the client and call for reasonable efforts to expedite litigation consistent with the client’s interests. Professional judgment and the client’s authority belong together.
Here is one change I would ask hourly civil firms to make: before each substantial new phase, agree with the client on a short written work plan. State what the next work should accomplish, its estimated hours and cost, the realistic cheaper alternative—or why none exists—and the point for deciding whether to continue.
Obtain the client’s agreement before materially expanding that budget. Allow narrowly defined, preauthorized urgent work to protect rights, with prompt notice afterward. Estimates remain estimates; they should trigger a conversation before surprise becomes debt. Keep the plan in the existing engagement record, short enough to use.
The point is to make the next expenditure answerable to the person funding it.
The question a client should be able to ask without embarrassment is simple: What will this next hour help us decide or achieve?
A bill can show that time was spent. Trust requires a persuasive account of why it was worth spending.
Sources: Gallup, September 30, 2026; ABA Model Rule 1.2(a), client authority over settlement; ABA Model Rule 3.2, expediting litigation.