PostPublius
U.S. national editionReporting checked

Education · Column

Before Blaming Parents, Show the Reading Lesson

By Victor Julian Hale · Written

A parent should be able to ask how a child is being taught to read and receive an answer about instruction. A judgment about the household will not do.

If the answer to a struggling reader is simply more practice at home, the school owes a further explanation: practice of what, taught how, and checked by whom? Asking parents to help is reasonable. Making parental effort the explanation for whatever goes wrong turns cooperation into an escape clause.

The 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress found that the national fourth-grade average reading score was two scale points below 2022 and five below 2019. Those figures describe a decline in performance. They do not identify its causes or measure how often schools blame families. My argument concerns where responsibility belongs when a child needs help.

Start with something a school can account for: the reading instruction it actually delivers.

The federal What Works Clearinghouse’s kindergarten-through-third-grade guide recommends teaching decoding—how to work out written words—and having every pupil read connected text daily. That means reading sentences and passages, as well as learning individual words. These are concrete instructional practices, not a guarantee that every difficulty will disappear.

A school should be able to explain which skill a child is learning, provide time to practice it during the school day, and show what the child can do afterward. When progress stalls, the next response should include examining the instruction and needed support.

That responsibility reaches beyond the classroom teacher. District leaders must provide usable materials, training and time, and identify staffing or specialist support they cannot yet supply. Telling an overloaded teacher to try harder merely moves the blame one desk closer to the child.

Families have responsibilities, too: support attendance, make time for practice where they can, and tell the school when something is getting in the way. Home reading can reinforce classroom teaching. But requests must be understandable and feasible, taking account of language, literacy, disability and working hours. A school and a family can begin helping together without waiting for either to prove itself blameless.

Here is a useful parent question: Which reading skill is my child being taught, what work shows the result, and when will we check whether the teaching needs to change?

Answer it using the child’s work and a review date. Keep the explanation brief enough to use. Then give the family a manageable way to help.

A child should not need a parent who can become an unpaid reading specialist to receive a serious attempt at teaching. The school’s promise must include the child whose home cannot fill the gaps.